Carbon Footprint Calculator Showdown

8

As good stewards of the planet we live on, it is often a good idea to measure our impact on the Earth and adjust accordingly. One of the best ways to do this is to calculate our carbon footprint. A carbon footprint is a rough measurement of greenhouse gases (GHG) that an individual, organization, event, or product produces. In this case we are looking at an individual assessment of GHG.

Luckily there are many online tools that will calculate your carbon footprint for free. We narrowed it down to our four favorite calculators, and compare the results for our imaginary wholesome character, Bob. We’ll talk more about Bob later, but first let’s look at our calculators.

CarbonFootprint.com

The Carbonfootprint.com calculator has calculators dedicated to home or business use, and allows you to create an account for more involved carbon footprint calculations. You can, for example, save your data for adjustment later, add more flights as you take them, add new or different cars, and generally fine tune your information to get a clear picture of your personal GHG impact.

The Carbonfootprint.com calculator uses the DEFRA Voluntary Reporting Guideline methodology, and incorporates up-to-date emission factors. The calculator is fairly robust, and even takes into account secondary services such as financial services and recreation.

The Nature Conservancy

The Nature Conservancy Carbon Footprint Calculator is not as robust as the Carbonfootprint.com version, but it does take into account such information as Home Energy, Driving and Flying, Food and Diet, and Recycling.

U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)

The U.S. EPA GHG Calculator is a solid calculator that strives to strike a balance between being in depth and easy to use. With that said, you may find that it is not ideally suited to some uses, such as businesses, but for an individual or home use it certainly can give a good estimate.

One thing that we found of interest is the EPA Greenhouse Gases Equivalences Calculator. This tool will help you visualize just what common greenhouse data is like – for example, 100 kilowatt-hours of electricity is equal to the CO2 emissions of 8.1 gallons of gas or 0.024 tons of waste recycled instead of sending it to the landfill.

TerraPass

The TerraPass Carbon Footprint Calculator supports both individual/families and businesses. The calculator uses information provided by the Environment Protection Agency and other governmental sources. TerraPass targets three main areas (driving, air travel and home) to gather information and come to a logical GHG footprint.

The Showdown

First. let’s meet Bob. Bob is a nice guy, and he tries to keep his emissions down to a minimum. Since Bob lives in a semi-urban area he doesn’t have the option for public transportation, and ends up driving his 2006 Honda Civic Hybrid about 8000 miles a year. Bob takes just one flight a year, and that is from his Newark, NJ home town to Las Vegas, Nevada for a relaxing vacation. Finally, his home uses both gas and electricity, and on average Bob spends about $91 on electricity and $98 on gas.

Next, we enter Bob’s information on the different calculators and compare the results. This we enter into a spreadsheet, and graph the results for your visual consumption. And the results are…

The Results

Interesting to note, even though the results are given in carbon dioxide tons, the answers vary by a wide margin between calculators. While I was expecting some deviation, the final results leave a lot of accuracy desired. The best advice I can give is to view the typical average reported per person and see how you stack up against it. Even that will not be a solid comparison, since our friend Bob was better than average for only three of the four calculators.

The key to using carbon footprint calculators, at least for now, is to pick one you like and stick with it. Get a starting number, and work to get it as low as practical. In this way you have a measuring system in place, and you can track your results to a comfortable conclusion that you are doing what you can for the planet.

Article by D. Salmons of TestFreaks appearing courtesy Celsias

photo: maticulous

Share.

About Author

Walter’s contributions to CleanTechies over the past 4 years have been instrumental in growing the publications social media channels via his ongoing editorial and data driven strategies. He is the founder and managing director of Sunflower Tax, a renewable energy tax and finance consultancy based in San Diego, California. Active in the San Diego clean technology community, participating in events sponsored by CleanTech San Diego, EcoTopics, and Cleantech Open San Diego, Walter has also been a presenter at numerous California Center for Sustainability (CCSE) programs. He currently serves as an adjunct professor at the University of San Diego School of Law where he teaches a course on energy taxation and policy.

8 Comments

  1. This is how the results of trackers usually ends up. When you are trying to calculate to much at once you get a lot of uncertainties, and the result will vary widely between the calculators. The different assumptions made doesn’t make it better. I agree that finding one that fit and minimizing the footprint is better.

    However, for a more accurate picture it is better to split up the tool, and use several specialised tools instead. One for travelling and the commute, one for electricity and water, one for food, one for clothes… It may be a bit tricky and clumsy, but it should work. Lord knows there are loads of them out there. One example, that I know quite well is Commute Greener!.

    • Ummm, who says it a sham? I think the facts speak for themselves. It does make me wonder how accurate the results of the calculators are when they are so different, but to think it’s a sham? I say no.

  2. o This is a wonderful opinion. The things mentioned are unanimous and needs to be appreciated by everyone.
    **********
    matthewpaul

  3. More accurate picture it is better to split up the tool, and use several specialized tools instead. often a good idea to measure our impact on the Earth and adjust accordingly.and one of the best way to calculate the carbon footprint.

  4. A carbon footprint is a rough measurement of greenhouse gases (GHG) that an individual, organization, event, or product produces.is to be protected our environment of green house effect and it is a technique of reduce the through carbon calculator.

  5. One of the best ways to do this is to calculate our carbon footprint.it is a saving process of our environment and the many gases is available in around of human so we are careful for harmful gases.

Join the Conversation