Star Architect Gehry: ‘A lot of LEED Is Given for Bogus Stuff’


The Northland Pines LEED appeal (a complete history is available here) and the Deepwater Horizon spill illustrate an inherent problem in any regulatory system–there will always be people who are looking to avoid regulation and commit fraud, and there will always be regulators looking to protect the status quo of regulations.

Many people have called for the abandonment, execution and other stringing up of the LEED system because there are flaws, perhaps including the ones identified in the Northland Pines appeal. Just in the past few weeks, in addition to Northland Pines, we have seen criticism of the USGBC for its wood credits and its alleged failure to take into consideration human health issues. Frank Gehry, from his vaunted position as one of the world’s most famous architects, has fired his own shots at the LEED system, saying:

I think the issue is finally a political one,” Gehry said. Referring to the LEED (for Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design) rating system…Gehry said: “A lot of LEED is given for bogus stuff.” The costs of making a green building are “enormous,” he said, and “they don’t pay back in your lifetime.”

He tried to clarify his position here a few days later.

But we cannot throw out the baby with the bathwater. LEED is the system that got people started thinking about the greenness of the built environment. It needs to progress, as all regulatory systems do, through amendment and challenge, like laws do. It is neither right for the USGBC to resist or be defensive to this natural regulatory process, nor is it right for LEED’s critics to suggest dismantling the entire LEED system. As my mother once said, there has to be something between everything and nothing.

Article by Shari Shapiro appearing courtesy Green Building Law Blog.

photo: senhormario



Have any Question or Comment?

One comment on “Star Architect Gehry: ‘A lot of LEED Is Given for Bogus Stuff’

Great points. Exactly my thoughts. People are forever criticizing the USGBC and LEED. The USGBC is a nonprofit organization. Give them a break. They are doing the best they can. And LEED is still somewhat new. Everything new – as you suggested – goes through its growing phase. We need to be grateful that LEED even broke the mold. It got us thinking about sustainability and green building, and our nation has come a long way since. People take the USGBC and LEED for granted without thinking about all the hard work that has gone into them. Sure, LEED might have a ways to go before it is perfect…wait, will it ever be perfect? No. It’ll get better, yes, but people will always complain!

Comments are closed for this post !!
Skip to toolbar